The Heroic Villain: All Roads Lead To Nowhere.
The Heroic Villain Book 3 is one of the most deflating endings I've heard in a long time.
There was a major time skip that effectively erased two or three books' worth of content. Important developments. Especially anything involving Bonnie? Are either rushed through or skipped entirely. An "awesome raid" that seemed like it was being set up as a real event is never actually shown. The story just states that it happened and moves on. It doesn't even describe it. It reads less like a scene and more like the author writing "and then this happened" and calling it a day.
Bonnie's arc suffers the most. She was slowly becoming one of the more interesting characters, but her personal story gets sidelined, retconned, or dropped. She all but fades and become irrelavant by book 3, almost to the point of being totally dropped as a character in a way. There is no real resolution for her, and she ends up with no one. Meanwhile, the book reveals that "Bob" is a girl, has Nate and Bob take a few weeks off to meet in real life, and suddenly declares them a couple. There is almost no chemistry shown between them beyond the fact that they liked arguing. There is also no proper scene where Nate and Bonnie's potential relationship is addressed or rejected. It just... doesn't happen. At all. The larger plot fares no better. None of the major hooks or conflicts are resolved in any satisfying way. There is no final confrontation with Lucas, no separation that forces Nate to build something of his own, and no real ******. The book simply ends. When I hit the epilogue after assuming there was still plenty of story left, it felt like a genuine letdown. The length of the book did not match the amount of unresolved material still on the table. The handling of romance throughout the series doesn't help. Book 3 opens by casually revealing that Bonnie slept with Lucas as well, with almost no setup or emotional context. Sex scenes in general are barely even fade-to-black; they read more like a single line stating that something happened before the story moves on. The series eventually commits to the idea that romance is part of the story instead of endlessly teasing it, which is something, but the execution is thin. It ends up feeling more like a checklist than something that developed between characters.
For comparison, Kirito in Sword Art Online had multiple women interested in him, but the story never had him cheat on or waver from Asuna. Their relationship was consistent and mattered to the plot. Here, relationships feel like afterthoughts that the story either skips or resolves off-screen.
Overall, The Heroic Villain Book series gets people invested in the characters, the world, and the drama, then just stops. Major threads are abandoned, character arcs are cut short, and the ending arrives without the payoff the earlier books were building toward. I've been more disappointed by this writter than I ever was by even the weakest of Goosebumps books, and those at least knew what kind of story they were telling. This one feels like the author ran out of interest and decided to wrap everything up as quickly as possible, then threw in a half assed apology at the end as to why his craft was "Taking so long" also, not to downplay anything this author may have gone through in his life but I don’t care for the author’s note at the end. Plenty of people go through real loss and still manage to finish the stories they started, or write something meaningful for the people they love. I’m sorry for your loss, but could you be the suffering artist who actually follows through on the plot points you set up? I mean you seem to understand the concept, you had Nate basically tell Lyu the exact same thing!
My head hurts. That wasn’t an ending. Nothing happened. There was no final battle, no real risk, no ******- nothing. They even had my least favorite character say “and that, my friends, is THE END” like it was supposed to be cute